Palin vs. Letterman vs. the outrage

June 17th, 2009 9:47 am · 22 comments

Hm, what a shocker.

So if you’ve been following the David Letterman-Sarah Palin business, you know that the right is in full professional OUTRAGE!!! mode. This is what they do; the only glue holding the conservative movement together is its resentment, its perpetual sense of victimhood. In this case there’s a legitimate reason for that grievance;Letterman’s joke about Palin’s daughter, even if we understand he thought he was talking about Bristol and not Willow, was offensive and tasteless and uncalled for.

C’mon, Dave, you’re better than that.

Nonetheless, the  OUTRAGE!!! that followed was about 5 percent legitimate, 95 percent manufactured - as exemplified by the fact that the big protest planned outside Letterman’s studio yesterday attracted a grand total of 15 protesters, who were outnumbered by the media.

The term “much ado about nothing” come to mind. But in fact those 15 showed that Letterman wasn’t the only one who could “hate”:

“How dare he?” asked yet a third, the most offensive of all. “When he has a bastard son, and a slut for a wife”

Sweet.

Other conservative talking points thrown around at the rally included, “Close the borders!” and “I only watch Fox News,” as well as the general sentiment that Jay Leno is a better host than Letterman.

You only watch Fox News. How surprising.

As we will get into in the print edition this week - this is a prime example of the conservatism of resentment, which first coalesced as a political force in the 1960s. When we do the OUTRAGE!!! bit in the vids, this is exactly what we’re talking about - this how-dare-you sense of grievance on display nightly on Fox News; the notion that the whole world is arrayed against common-sense workaday conservatives - you know, the people who ran the show for the better part of this decade.

The base is perpetually outraged; we know this. But for this perpetual outrage to have an effect beyond the base, it has to seem legitimate to the vast bulk of what Nixon called the “silent Americans.” But the right has used this cultural OUTRAGE!!! as its motivator for 40 years. You get into the Boy-Who-Cried-Wolf syndrome; even when there are legitimate things to be outraged about, we’ve heard it all so often, and it’s become so tiresome, that it ceases to be politically effective.

That the likes of me can so publicly laugh at the Outrage Machine, yet the right keeps on cranking it up anyway, is a sign that as strategy, outrage is outdated. Don’t tell ‘em, though - hell, you don’t want to deprive me of a catch phrase, do you?

Update: Actually, the funniest bit about the rally is this:

Ziegler scowled as a huge red-bearded man carrying a placard reading “I’m a Right-Wing Lunatic” whirled around and shrieked such sentiments as “I hate it when people tell jokes on television!” “Jesus is speaking to me!” and “Letterman is worse than Hitler!” (Turns out the guy was a plant from the Ron & Fez Show on Sirius XM Radio.)

We ain’t the only ones making jokes about the OUTRAGE!!!

Update 2: And here you go:

The woman in the yellow? OUTRAGE!!!

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Netvouz
  • DZone
  • ThisNext
  • MisterWong
  • Wists

  22 comments  Tags: Conservatism of resentment · Media

There are currently 22 comments on this blog post
View Topic | Comment on this blog
skeptic2
6/17/09
9:53 AM
I'm OUTRAGED that it took so long for you to comment on this. Who said you could take a vacation?
mam0412
6/17/09
10:16 AM
QUOTE (skeptic2 @ Jun 17 2009, 09:53 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm OUTRAGED that it took so long for you to comment on this. Who said you could take a vacation?


I'm outraged that you're outraged! tongue.gif
Beth
6/17/09
10:18 AM
I'm sort of over it all ready! Can we move on?
StrobeSML
6/17/09
10:29 AM
QUOTE (Beth @ Jun 17 2009, 10:18 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm sort of over it all ready! Can we move on?


Fine by me.
Goldilocks
6/17/09
11:55 AM
QUOTE (StrobeSML @ Jun 17 2009, 09:29 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Fine by me.


And me. But you know Gil, he will rant and rave about this for the next month, like he did with her "wink". I think Gil has a secret crush on Palin.
citydweller
6/17/09
12:50 PM
The video of the "protest" was actually rather telling, I think.

Forget that only 15 outraged! wingers actually bothered to show up. Take a look at them; they don't really look like "whackos", per-se. They look pretty normal, or average, at least on the surface. People you see every day on the streets, in the grocery store, next to you in traffic.

But then listen to Teh Outrage. Sure, they're fired up about Letterman (VERBAL PEDOPHILE!!!!!), but they're also just as fired up about everything under the sun, and once the floodgates are open it all starts pouring out. Hate on tap. And they're so completely sure of themselves that they not only don't seem to notice the looks they're getting from the crowd, but they seem to actually believe they're taking a golden opportunity to set us all straight, about all of it.

And they're absolutely smug about it.

This, I think, is where Gil is right to keep the wingers on our radar. They really could pose a threat to the strength of our nation's fabric, and they're all but invisible in that you can't "tell one" just by looking at them (usually). Until you push one of the buttons installed by Rush, Fox et al. Then they lose all capacity to reason past the emotional gravitas that has them locked into a simplistic, child-like logic that defies all arguments.

There is danger here. I mean, what if the winger installation team installs enough buttons to approach a "silent winger majority"? Not a true statistical majority, mind you, but a voting one. Seemingly ordinary people who go to work, play with their kids, support charity, attend church, and go to their polling place and vote for madness. Give blood on Wednesday, help coach soccer Friday, vote to outlaw homosexuality on Tuesday.

Keep showing us the wingers Gil. The rest of us need to recognize the day when we have to get off our butts and go to the polls.
UncommonSense
6/17/09
3:18 PM
QUOTE (citydweller @ Jun 17 2009, 12:50 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
The video of the "protest" was actually rather telling, I think.

Forget that only 15 outraged! wingers actually bothered to show up. Take a look at them; they don't really look like "whackos", per-se. They look pretty normal, or average, at least on the surface. People you see every day on the streets, in the grocery store, next to you in traffic.

But then listen to Teh Outrage. Sure, they're fired up about Letterman (VERBAL PEDOPHILE!!!!!), but they're also just as fired up about everything under the sun, and once the floodgates are open it all starts pouring out. Hate on tap. And they're so completely sure of themselves that they not only don't seem to notice the looks they're getting from the crowd, but they seem to actually believe they're taking a golden opportunity to set us all straight, about all of it.

And they're absolutely smug about it.

This, I think, is where Gil is right to keep the wingers on our radar. They really could pose a threat to the strength of our nation's fabric, and they're all but invisible in that you can't "tell one" just by looking at them (usually). Until you push one of the buttons installed by Rush, Fox et al. Then they lose all capacity to reason past the emotional gravitas that has them locked into a simplistic, child-like logic that defies all arguments.

There is danger here. I mean, what if the winger installation team installs enough buttons to approach a "silent winger majority"? Not a true statistical majority, mind you, but a voting one. Seemingly ordinary people who go to work, play with their kids, support charity, attend church, and go to their polling place and vote for madness. Give blood on Wednesday, help coach soccer Friday, vote to outlaw homosexuality on Tuesday.

Keep showing us the wingers Gil. The rest of us need to recognize the day when we have to get off our butts and go to the polls.


I'm curious - what makes a winger? I am aware of not a single person, of a conservative mindset, that wishes to outlaw homosexuality - if such a notion would even be possible. I am aware of many who have opinions that homosexuality is a sin, but that is a religious ponderance - to be debated or discussed within the context of church, family etc.

I am aware of many conservative minded people, like myself, who support full rights of survivorship, ownership, transferrence etc for all couples. Essentially, all the business communal benefits that a traditional man-woman marriage affords. I am aware of many who oppose efforts to compel a Priest, Preacher, Iman or Rabbi to perform a wedding ceremony for a homosexual couple. Do these people counts as "wingers"?

I think there is enough OUTRAGE, of the faux variety put out by most talkingheads, Gil included. Let's face it, his ratings and his rantings punch his meal ticket. Letterman's joke was in poor taste, period. Jokes that target a child are just bad form, and Letterman knows it, else he would not have apologized.

But, what gives pause to many conservatives is what lead our society to a point where such unsound judgement is, by some, defended? Yet, far too many are willing to dismiss these people as a lunatic fringe, unworthy of consideration in political discourse.

What has many conservatives concerned is that they notice a decline in national standards corresponding with a decline in national achievement, national output and national advancement. Whether there is a correlation or causation present is open to discussion. Within that discussion, all viewpoints deserve to be respected and heard.

Basically, if we can't stand together and talk as friends, what hope have we?

BTW - Rush, Hannity, Colmes, Olberman, Savage, Maddow do not represent the stalwart peoples of the United States of America. But they sure do drive us apart, don't they. So also can the smaller fish in the pond.
justplainjoe
6/17/09
3:48 PM
note to gil....nixon called them the "silent majority" not the "silent americans". it was emotional manipulation at it's finest. suddenly people said " yeah, that's me." and they identified with nixon.
nixon shrewdly created the impression that most americans were on his side but were silent about their support for his escaltion of the war in vietnam.
too bad nixon really was a crook. in the end he did himself in.
you can tell a lot about a persons values , or lack thereof, by what outrages them.
torture, rendition, corruption, war based on lies, a few hundred thousand dead? eh, no biggie.
but when a talkshow host tells an off color joke after my bedtime about saint sara the adulteress with a knocked up teenybobber, they go berserk.
that's wingy and it's nutty as well.LOL
oh geez
6/17/09
4:04 PM
Joe, you're really a mean person. I tried, but you just like to make fun of anyone who doesn't think the way you do.
does that make you a winger...and gil is the biggest winger of them all. you're so far off to one side...winger, correct?
If you don't see what's going on...that's really sad.
Maybe you should start looking ahead instead of looking behind all the time. It's going to be a hell of a ride coming up.
so joe, keep drinking YOUR kool-aid.
and Nixon was his own undoing.....obama will be the undoing of our country.
ArtVandolay
6/17/09
4:07 PM
QUOTE (justplainjoe @ Jun 17 2009, 03:48 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
but when a talkshow host tells an off color joke after my bedtime about saint sara the adulteress with a knocked up teenybobber, they go berserk.
that's wingy and it's nutty as well.LOL


Pot: Your black

Kettle: I am?

Anyway this is over. Letterman looks like the old fool that he is, Palin come out on top this time.
NOW looks bad too.
justplainjoe
6/17/09
4:37 PM
QUOTE (oh geez @ Jun 17 2009, 04:04 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Joe, you're really a mean person. I tried, but you just like to make fun of anyone who doesn't think the way you do.
does that make you a winger...and gil is the biggest winger of them all. you're so far off to one side...winger, correct?
If you don't see what's going on...that's really sad.
Maybe you should start looking ahead instead of looking behind all the time. It's going to be a hell of a ride coming up.
so joe, keep drinking YOUR kool-aid.
and Nixon was his own undoing.....obama will be the undoing of our country.



i simply observed that there was no outrage when we killed a hundred thousand innocents and tortured people and spend hundreds of billions on a war based on lies but the outrage over a dirty joke is gigantic.
if you think that makes me mean it's because your conscience is bothering you , as well it should.LOL
Hammer
6/17/09
5:16 PM
Palin and her whole family are a joke.The only ones outraged were the people with nothing better to bitch about.Sara will grab on to anything that will keep her name out there.It doesn`t matter if it`s her kids or anyone else in her family.She should thank Dave for bringing her back into the spot light for another five mins.She really thinks she has a shot at holding a national political position. rolleyes.gif dry.gif
ArtVandolay
6/17/09
5:34 PM
QUOTE (Hammer @ Jun 17 2009, 05:16 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Palin and her whole family are a joke.The only ones outraged were the people with nothing better to bitch about.Sara will grab on to anything that will keep her name out there.It doesn`t matter if it`s her kids or anyone else in her family.She should thank Dave for bringing her back into the spot light for another five mins.She really thinks she has a shot at holding a national political position. rolleyes.gif dry.gif


More lefty spin rope a dope dodge and weave, chuck and duck now you have to defend a fading comic.
Letterman Started this nonsense. Not Palin. How is this a play by her to get her name out there?
This ought to be good.
Anyone notice it's the left who can't let go of this story?
mam0412
6/17/09
8:32 PM
QUOTE (ArtVandolay @ Jun 17 2009, 05:34 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
More lefty spin rope a dope dodge and weave, chuck and duck now you have to defend a fading comic.
Letterman Started this nonsense. Not Palin. How is this a play by her to get her name out there?
This ought to be good.
Anyone notice it's the left who can't let go of this story?


Art, you're late the party. Check out the thread in the Politics section. Then move on. It's over.
Daisy Lee Myers
6/17/09
8:49 PM
QUOTE (Hammer @ Jun 17 2009, 05:16 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Palin and her whole family are a joke.The only ones outraged were the people with nothing better to bitch about.Sara will grab on to anything that will keep her name out there.It doesn`t matter if it`s her kids or anyone else in her family.She should thank Dave for bringing her back into the spot light for another five mins.She really thinks she has a shot at holding a national political position. rolleyes.gif dry.gif


hammer:

a little comic relief..

I read in NYT forum this poster signature:

"David Letterman is an institution, but Sarah Palin belongs in an institution."


enough said.

g-night
oh geez
6/17/09
9:04 PM
lets see if he makes jokes about the little obama girls. I doubt it.
and that would be just as tasteless.
one thing about Palin....she defended her daughter and all the other little girls who are targets of perverted old men. never did say anything about the "slutty flight attendant look". maybe she does has a sense of humor after all.
don't even bother with the replies...I know them all already.
lol.....
Kate
6/17/09
9:09 PM
QUOTE (oh geez @ Jun 17 2009, 09:04 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
never did say anything about the "slutty flight attendant look". maybe she does has a sense of humor after all.
Actually, she did comment on the "slutty flight attendant" remark, stating about an insult to all flight attendants. She commented on it during an interview with Matt Lauer on TODAY.
Goldilocks
6/17/09
9:19 PM
QUOTE (citydweller @ Jun 17 2009, 11:50 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
This, I think, is where Gil is right to keep the wingers on our radar. They really could pose a threat to the strength of our nation's fabric, and they're all but invisible in that you can't "tell one" just by looking at them (usually). Until you push one of the buttons installed by Rush, Fox et al. Then they lose all capacity to reason past the emotional gravitas that has them locked into a simplistic, child-like logic that defies all arguments.


Same could be said about those who follow the MSNBC leftnutry. Push one of the buttons installed by Olbermann and Maddow, and they go off on their crazy irrational, no common sense hateful tangents.
justplainjoe
6/17/09
9:51 PM
QUOTE (oh geez @ Jun 17 2009, 09:04 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
lets see if he makes jokes about the little obama girls. I doubt it.
and that would be just as tasteless.
one thing about Palin....she defended her daughter and all the other little girls who are targets of perverted old men. never did say anything about the "slutty flight attendant look". maybe she does has a sense of humor after all.
don't even bother with the replies...I know them all already.
lol.....

yeah right. she wears mini skirts and high heels and then gets pist when men look at her. we all know the type and we do not like her.
sorry but there is a word for her that almost every man in america understands.
and we all know which letter it begins with, see.LOL
ReverendAlobar
6/17/09
11:03 PM
QUOTE (Goldilocks @ Jun 17 2009, 09:19 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Same could be said about those who follow the MSNBC leftnutry. Push one of the buttons installed by Olbermann and Maddow, and they go off on their crazy irrational, no common sense hateful tangents.


Care to cite one?
ArtVandolay
6/18/09
7:15 AM
QUOTE (mam0412 @ Jun 17 2009, 08:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Art, you're late the party. Check out the thread in the Politics section. Then move on. It's over.


Mam - I know all about that one. I hosted that party and proved my point many times.
Maybe the left can start talking about how wonderful BHO is instead of worrying about republicans all Day.
'Cause like...what has he done?
skeptic2
6/18/09
8:21 AM
QUOTE (ArtVandolay @ Jun 18 2009, 07:15 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Mam - I know all about that one. I hosted that party and proved my point many times.
Maybe the left can start talking about how wonderful BHO is instead of worrying about republicans all Day.
'Cause like...what has he done?

Extended benefits to same sex partners of federal employees and is working to expand power of the Federal Reserve.
biggrin.gif
View Topic | Comment on this blog