When Good Drive goes bad

June 25th, 2008 2:27 pm · 9 comments

If you spend any time on Good Drive, you’ve probably noticed it: The new stoplight at Noll Drive.

It was flashing yellow last time I was through, but it will be operational soon enough. And it’s too bad, because one of the nice things about Good Drive is that it hasn’t been cluttered with stoplights, like Rohrerstown Road. With the exception of the light at either end (Harrisburg Pike and Columbia Avenue) and at Marietta Pike, it was a straight shot.

But, of course, the big Stauffers of Kissel Hill expansion is destined to generate more traffic, as are the smaller offices being built in the nearby complex. So we throw up another light on the new road in order to regulate the increasing traffic, even though the original goal of the new road was to be a straight shot, with as few lights as possible. Funny how that all gets tossed out the window. Though I suspect it’s destined to be.

Which is to say that there are some other proposals for new roads elsewhere in Lancaster County; the long-awaited Strasburg Bypass, the possible new Route 23. Always, these new roads are touted as a means of reducing congestion, and for a while maybe they do - though Rohrerstown Road is still a mess, and it was supposed to be less of a mess when Good Drive opened.

But the suspicion, whenever anyone pitches the idea of a new road, is that it will open upĀ  new land to development, and that this in fact is one of the biggest reasons local officials get behind the plan - sometimes, claiming exactly the opposite. I figure that’s probably right; we already know that the big landowners in Strasburg are chief among those interested in a bypass, and a new Route 23 would open up huge swaths of farmland to development.

None of that’s to say that these formerly landlocked sites shouldn’t be developed; the obvious rationale (from a municipal standpoint) is that the improvements will generate more tax revenue. And we all like more tax revenue, don’t we?

It’s just that this quest for new revenue/more developable land seems, sometimes, to be driving the bus - and we shouldn’t kid ourselves otherwise. Because I doubt that light at the corner of Good and Noll drives will be the last one installed; give it 10 years and we’ll have even more doctors’ offices, even more retirement villas along the stretch, lots more traffic. And then Good Drive will be so bad that you’ll wind up back on Rohrerstown Road, where you started in the first place.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Netvouz
  • DZone
  • ThisNext
  • MisterWong
  • Wists

  9 comments  Tags: Development · Lancaster

There are currently 9 comments on this blog post
View Topic | Comment on this blog
dragonrider
6/25/08
2:39 PM
QUOTE(Lancaster Online @ Jun 25 2008, 02:30 PM) [snapback]405015[/snapback]


Post your thoughts and comments about this blog post.
Sometimes like an Illinois politician you buy up land and then propose a new highway and voila instant rich.
Livin-in-Lancaster
6/26/08
2:32 PM
Gil, I agree with you 100%. It's all about the developers making money. Remember that when they propose 5 to 10 houses per acre. Remember that when the traffic lights appear at each corner and your commute time triples and you idle away your $4.00 gasoline.



Remember that when the school buses need to make 2 to 3 trips per bus using $6 diesel fuel. Of course the density will require more schools and more taxes.



Again, it's all about the developers making money. Does anything else in life really matter?



Eventually the suburbs will become urban, with no clear deliniation between suburban and city. The land will be gone, the farmers market will be located miles away, food costs will go up. But at least the land will be gone so the developers who promoted higher density can move on to suck up what is left in another county.



It's all good. Who really cares anymore?



Then we can all make believe we live in Europe and ride our bikes and mopeds to work, even those who work in Phillly and Baltimore.









gsmart
6/26/08
2:45 PM
QUOTE(Livin-in-Lancaster @ Jun 26 2008, 02:32 PM) [snapback]405378[/snapback]
Then we can all make believe we live in Europe and ride our bikes and mopeds to work, even those who work in Phillly and Baltimore.




well, the upshot is you will no longer be able to live in Lancaster and work in Philly or Baltimore unless you have the means to do so.

dc
6/26/08
3:08 PM
QUOTE(gsmart @ Jun 26 2008, 02:45 PM) [snapback]405392[/snapback]
well, the upshot is you will no longer be able to live in Lancaster and work in Philly or Baltimore unless you have the means to do so.
Maybe they could put one of those small town stops along the Amtrak lines (like the one in Mt. Joy) beside the Long's Park border. They could add a parking lot, and all those people could scooter over to there, and catch the train to Philly.......
AngelFace
6/26/08
10:12 PM
I am not at all unhappy about the Good/Noll light. If you have ever sat behind three cars from Homestead Village trying to make a left on to Good Drive, then you understand the light. I was tempted to just turn the car off to save gas! When the Crossings shopping center goes in you are going to see a light at Marietta and Farmingdale Rd. as well.
anonymouse
6/27/08
9:19 AM
QUOTE
When the Crossings shopping center goes in you are going to see a light at Marietta and Farmingdale Rd. as well.


Isn't that why the township is reclassifying Farmingdale to "a local road" from a "connector" road? I heard township officials also mention that the railroad was virtually certain to close raiload crossing on Farmingdale soon anyway, meaning the Crossings traffic would have to use Bennett and Good.

gsmart
6/27/08
9:53 AM
QUOTE(AngelFace @ Jun 26 2008, 10:12 PM) [snapback]405489[/snapback]
I am not at all unhappy about the Good/Noll light. If you have ever sat behind three cars from Homestead Village trying to make a left on to Good Drive, then you understand the light. I was tempted to just turn the car off to save gas! When the Crossings shopping center goes in you are going to see a light at Marietta and Farmingdale Rd. as well.




I understand it, absolutely.



But, then again - drove through the light the other day coming from Marietta, towards Columbia Ave.; light at Marietta turned green, as the traffic approached the light at Good and Noll, that light went red.



New light isn't synchronized.



Cue Casey Stengel: Can't anyone here play this game?

tugrad
6/27/08
1:53 PM
QUOTE(gsmart @ Jun 27 2008, 09:53 AM) [snapback]405614[/snapback]

I understand it, absolutely.



But, then again - drove through the light the other day coming from Marietta, towards Columbia Ave.; light at Marietta turned green, as the traffic approached the light at Good and Noll, that light went red.



New light isn't synchronized.



Cue Casey Stengel: Can't anyone here play this game?

Wasn't Good Rd proposed to ease the congestion on Roherstown Rd? By building along Good it seems they are just creating more congestion.
AngelFace
6/27/08
1:58 PM
QUOTE(gsmart @ Jun 27 2008, 09:53 AM) [snapback]405614[/snapback]

I understand it, absolutely.



But, then again - drove through the light the other day coming from Marietta, towards Columbia Ave.; light at Marietta turned green, as the traffic approached the light at Good and Noll, that light went red.



New light isn't synchronized.



Cue Casey Stengel: Can't anyone here play this game?


You are now singing my song! They have yet to synch all the lights from Park City toward the P.O. on H'bg Pike and it's been a couple of YEARS since the road improvements -- along with lots of promises/promises. Columbia Ave. heading out of town is also an inch by inch affair because of unsynched lights. And PennDot doesn't give two hoots.
View Topic | Comment on this blog