The NIE-jerk response

December 5th, 2007 4:04 pm · 9 comments

Fox, doing it’s usual bang-up job:

On Monday, the day the NIE conclusions surprised the world, three of the four Fox News programs made no mention of the story at all. The exception with Special Report with Brit Hume, which featured a discussion between Hume, conservative media personality Fred Barnes, conservative media personality Mort Kondracke, and conservative media personality Charles Krauthammer.

It was a brief discussion, but viewers heard Kondracke argue, “[Iranians] are still trying to reprocess uranium. If they find out how to reprocess uranium, it’s a short step from that to a nuclear program.” Barnes argued, “Well, look, this is not a case for diplomacy. That’s not what worked.” And Krauthammer concluded that intelligence officials might be wrong.

Which leads us to last night’s programs.

* Special Report ran a piece Chief Washington Correspondent Jim Angle, who told viewers, “If the latest NIE is, in fact, accurate, Iran abandoned its nuclear weapons program in 2003, not long after President Bush said it was part of an axis of evil, which made some people squeamish, raising the question of whether Iran backed off nuclear weapons in spite of the Bush comments, or in part because of them.”

* Special Report also featured a discussion — with the same four conservative voices from Monday night — in which viewers heard Fred Barnes say, “It’s an estimate. It’s a guess. And there are good guesses, and they describe this latest thing as they have high confidence. Well, I don’t have high confidence in it.”

* The Big Story led with a lengthy report on the Stacy Peterson case, another lengthy report on a Tampa teacher who had sex with a student, and then another lengthy report on Norman Hsu. After these gripping news items, John Gibson asked, “We’ve got the IAEA saying they’re not trying to make one. We have got Ahmadinejad saying we just cascaded 3,000 centrifuges, we’re on our way. Who should we believe?”

* On Hannity & Colmes, Alan Colmes broached the subject, asking for responses from Republican pollster Frank Luntz and conservative activist Kristen Powers. Both guests said the NIE is not to be trusted.

* The O’Reilly Factor featured a fairly lengthy discussion about the NIE on Iran. That’s the good news. The bad news is, the discussion was with former U.N. Ambassador John Bolton, who called for a congressional investigation into an NIE he dismisses, and right-wing personality Glenn Beck, who said the NIE might be right, but it’s proof of Bush’s greatness.

And people wonder why Fox News viewers are so confused about reality.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Netvouz
  • DZone
  • ThisNext
  • MisterWong
  • Wists

  9 comments  Tags: War in Iran

There are currently 9 comments on this blog post
View Topic | Comment on this blog
usedmeat
12/6/07
12:05 AM
Fox News, a perfect example of an oxymoron. Just like its viewers, morons as dumb as an ox. laugh.gif
Whirlwind
12/7/07
6:30 AM
Sadly, many will take faux's reporting (opinions?) as gospel.



I don't care what Fred said at the water cooler, it was on tv. They said the NIE is all wrong.

justplainjoe
12/7/07
7:02 AM
diplomacy hasn't worked? well he's half right because we haven't tried diplomacy.

here's what they want you to believe...

in august the intel chief told bush there was a major change in the intelligence assessment of iran and nukes.

bush didn't bother to ask what that was.and he continued to be bellicose.

there were no presidential daily briefings between august and last wednesday when bush was told the full story.

two weeks earlier there was a meeting which cheney attended discussing this very subject and cheney did not tell bush?huh? is that treasonous?

but then they tell us that bush jr briefed the israeli prime minister on the monday before the wednesday that bush jr claimed to have found out what was in the report.

these people are liars and anyone who wants to defend them at the expense of the constuitution is a stooge.

usedmeat
12/7/07
11:50 AM
None of this is really Bush's fault.
It's the way his White House staff has to deliver the information. From the PDB memo that warned of 911, thru Katrina, to the latest NIE his staff has to send the information to Japan where it's programmed into Nintendo cartridges then shipped back to the US.
To get the message thru to George the Lesser the news has to be delivered by Mario. laugh.gif
grieker
12/7/07
12:24 PM
QUOTE(usedmeat @ Dec 7 2007, 11:50 AM) [snapback]341216[/snapback]
None of this is really Bush's fault.
It's the way his White House staff has to deliver the information. From the PDB memo that warned of 911, thru Katrina, to the latest NIE his staff has to send the information to Japan where it's programmed into Nintendo cartridges then shipped back to the US.
To get the message thru to George the Lesser the news has to be delivered by Mario. laugh.gif


Hey ConfusedTeat, did you forget your medication today? You seem xtra grumpy (if that's possible) today for some reason. rolleyes.gif

ArtVandolay
12/7/07
3:34 PM
QUOTE(grieker @ Dec 7 2007, 01:24 PM) [snapback]341231[/snapback]


Hey ConfusedTeat, did you forget your medication today? You seem xtra grumpy (if that's possible) today for some reason. rolleyes.gif





I don't know, I've seen Meat much more ticked off in the past. A goal of mine is to find one issue in which we can agree on.





18% Believe Iran has Stopped Nuclear Weapons Development Program!



http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_con...lopment_program

Artie See
12/7/07
5:23 PM
QUOTE(usedmeat @ Dec 7 2007, 11:50 AM) [snapback]341216[/snapback]
None of this is really Bush's fault.
Actually, there is an entire team in the basement of the White House that translates national issues into elementary school English, so GW Bush can understand it. THEN someone must work very hard to keep GW Bush's attention long enough to finish reading the translation.

Meanwhile, Dick Cheney rules the U.S. from an undisclosed location...
harv1
12/7/07
6:20 PM
Bush needs to strap that backpack monitor/prompter on again. Oh, wait... Karen Hughes has left the building...
usedmeat
12/7/07
11:49 PM
QUOTE(grieker @ Dec 7 2007, 12:24 PM) [snapback]341231[/snapback]


Hey ConfusedTeat, did you forget your medication today? You seem xtra grumpy (if that's possible) today for some reason. rolleyes.gif



Thank you, greiker. You too, Art.
View Topic | Comment on this blog